Nissan Juke or V6 Dodge Challenger? Yes it's a weird choice

So I'm between two cars, and looking to find one that fits my lifestyle and will make me happier and more comfortable in the day-to-day.
What to know about me.
23 y/o (almost 24) male in final years of college, working as a server at a restaurant chain to make ends meet. 6'7" tall 220 pounds (so pretty thin). Married to a wonderful lady who I won't have kids with for at least 5-10 years. Going to be going on a couple road trips in the next few months/years. Accidentally wrecked my 2011 Honda CRZ hybrid 6 months ago and looking to move on.
Stylistically I appreciate both cars, the juke and challenger, I like unusual cars. Both are roughly $10k which is what I intend to spend in cash, money isn't the issue it's just about finding which is the better car. I'm not looking for other options. It's just between the two. Wife wants me to get the Juke, I also kind of really want the juke. But the challenger is within my range and is a nicer car, more comfortable, cushier. Wife says she'd be okay with a challenger if I really wanted it, because it is my money, but I'm definitely on the fence. Help please. (pros and cons)

Read more: Nissan Juke or V6 Dodge Challenger? Yes it's a weird choice